Our Cases

Browse Our Past Legal Cases

Browse a selection of cases where the 1851 Center has stood up for constitutional limits on government power and defended the rights of Ohio citizens, property owners, and small businesses.

Wide view of a lush green crop field at dusk with a distant tree line and farm buildings on the horizon.

Data Centers Cannot Seize Ohio Farmland

 Legal Center intervenes in Power Siting Board to stop eminent domain for Meta Data Center Pipeline   Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today moved to intervene in the Ohio Power Siting Board to stop a Meta affiliate from using eminent domain to...

service-dog

Legal Center Moves to Stop Unconstitutional Fair Housing Shakedowns

LEGAL CENTER MOVES TO STOP UNCONSTITUTIONAL “FAIR HOUSING” SHAKEDOWNS FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE May 24, 2025 Dayton nonprofit hires actors to manufacture discrimination by entrapping and shakedown unsuspecting homeowners.   Dayton, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional...

uncle-sam-point-of-sale

Ohio Cities Cannot Gut Search Warrant Requirement

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE October 2, 2023 Ohio Cities Cannot Gut Search Warrant Requirement North Canton’s crusade for warrants to enter homes based solely on lack of consent from homeowners is unconstitutional. Stark County, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law...

suburban street with houses

Cleveland Heights Attack on Outside Ownership Unconstitutional

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE February 15, 2023   Ohio cities may not charge extra assessments to nonresidents who own homes within their limits.   Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law this week moved to enjoin the City of Cleveland Heights...

camera

Ohio City Forced to Return $3.3 Million in Unconstitutional Fees

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE December 21, 2022   Cincinnati charged "alarm fees" to homeowners and businesses protecting themselves with security alarms.   Cincinnati, OH – The Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas today ordered the City of Cincinnati to return the...

baby

Bill to Criminalize Home-Births and Midwifery: Unlawful and Unwise

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE December 1, 2022   HB 496 would violate the Health Care Freedom Amendment and felonize natural births in Ohio   Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law this week intervened to object to any further advancement of HB 496 in...

luggage in hotel

Milford Airbnb Ban Unconstitutional

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE October 4, 2022   Ohio cities unlawfully trample property rights when they criminalize vacation rentals.   Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law this week moved to enjoin the City of Milford’s severe new restrictions...

mask

Ohio Court: State Mask Mandates Unconstitutional

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE April 6, 2021   In Ashland County, ”any further attempt to enforce mask restrictions will result in further restraint of any such attempt.” Ashland, OH – An Ohio Court late Wednesday cast doubt on the lawfulness of the state’s mask mandates,...

Ohio flag

Ohio’s Pandemic Reform Bill: Good and Bad

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE March 24, 2021   Ohio General Assembly adopted key 1851 Center recommendations, but other than leveling legal playing field, leaves Governor and ODH unchecked   Columbus, OH – In overriding the Ohio Governor’s veto and enacting Senate...

sign "protection of property"

Akron Federal Court: CDC Eviction Ban Unlawful

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE March 10, 2021   Centers for Disease Control has no authority to administratively criminalize removal of tenants who refuse to pay Akron, OH – A federal court on Wednesday determined that the Centers for Disease Control exceeded its limited...

bar

Ohio Court: Health Departments Cannot Suspend Licenses Over Masks

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE July 23, 2020 Ashland County Restaurant is protected by Ohio Constitution’s limits on arbitrary administrative action Ashland, OH – In the first attempt within Ohio to suspend a business license for an alleged mask violation, an Ohio Court of...

bar

Health Departments Cannot Suspend Licenses Over Masks

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE July 22, 2020 Ohio Restaurants are protected by Ohio Constitution’s limit on arbitrary administrative enactments. Ashland, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today, on behalf of an Ohio restaurant shut down by its local health department...

Daycare

Ohio Daycares Sue to End Unlawful Pandemic Regulations

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE June 23, 2020 Ohio Dept. of Health has no Constitutional Authority to Overrule State Legislation Protecting Parents, Children, and Daycares Mason, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today filed suit on behalf of 40 daycare centers across...

Water slide photo.

Another Ohio Court Slams Forced Closures as Unconstitutional

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE June 12, 2020 Another Ohio Court Slams Forced Closures as Unconstitutional Statute Health Department relies on is unconstitutional and it has no authority to close businesses or create its own penalties Kalahari wins right to open immediately...

Roller-coaster

Cedar Point, Kings Island, Kalahari Sue to Open

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE June 5, 2020 Cedar Point, Kings Island, Kalahari Sue to Open Ohio Dept. of Health has no Constitutional Authority to Keep these Businesses Closed Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today filed suit to enjoin the Ohio Department...

diner

1851 Fights 90 Days in Jail for “Disobedient” Ohio Diner Owner

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE May 27, 2020 1851 Fights 90 Days in Jail for “Disobedient” Ohio Diner Owner 1851 Center Moves to Dismiss Criminal Charges in State’s First Criminal Case for Violating Pandemic Orders Cambridge, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today...

barbell

Ohio Court: Forced Closure of Gyms Unconstitutional

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE May 20, 2020 Ohio Court: Forced Closure of Gyms Unconstitutional Health Department has no authority to close all business or create its own penalties Painesville, OH – An Ohio Court of Common Pleas Wednesday morning enjoined the Ohio Governor and...

barbell

Ohio Gyms Sue Health Department for Right to Exist

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE May 12, 2020 Ohio Gyms Sue Health Department for Right to Exist Even in emergencies, the Ohio Constitution protects businesses from vague and discriminatory enactments. Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today, on behalf of 35...

office

Lawsuit: Ohio Ban on “Non-Essential Business” Unconstitutional

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE April 16, 2020 Legal Center:  Ohio Ban on “Non-Essential Business” Unconstitutional Without hearings where the State justifies its decisions, the ban violates Due Process Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today moved to enjoin...

flag preamble

Constitutional Rights During the Quarantine

Ohio Department of Health’s Orders may be prudent, but are largely unenforceable Columbus, OH – State and federal constitutions entitle Ohioans to protections, which remain in place even as the state implements seemingly prudent restrictions to combat the COVID-19...

Stevens-home

Columbus Historic District Fines Unconstitutional

Ohio cities violate private property rights when they criminalize landscaping and gardening Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law has filed an action in federal court on behalf of a Columbus couple threatened with 60 days in jail and fines of $100 per...

Downloaded Hands musician playing the flute in the orchestra closeup

Columbus “Admissions Tax” Will be in Court and on Ballot

1851 Center spearheads legal action to protect citizens from municipal “ticket taxes” on arts and entertainment that force funding of private art Columbus, OH - The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today moved to protect Ohioans from special city taxes on tickets to...

Remote home control/ Smart home control on tablet.

Ohio Cities Cannot Prohibit Use of Security Alarms

Cincinnati's "alarm tax" violates homeowners’ right to communicate, freedom from double-taxation The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law has moved to invalidate a municipal ordinance that forbids homeowners from protecting themselves with a home security alarm unless...

steal

1851 to Supreme Court: Forced Funding of Unions Violates Free Speech

1851 Center Amicus Brief argues that government employees who aren't union members can't be forced to pay hundreds of dollars per year to unions Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law petitioned the United States Supreme Court to rule in favor of the...

warrantless inspection

Court: $100 Per Day Fines for Yard Signs Unconstitutional

Ohio city's ban on political yard signs except directly before and after elections violates free speech, property rights August 30, 2017: Toledo, OH - A federal court prohibited an Ohio city from fining citizens who display political yard signs for longer than 67...

taxburden

Lower Your Local Tax Bill This Summer

1851 Center teaches citizens how to use local initiatives to place tax cut proposals on the ballot Are you tired of do-nothing politicians but still looking to make a difference in government? Have you recently opened an envelope with an unacceptably-large property...

Installation of the distribution unit of heating and water supply network. Frame for connecting pipes in the trench of ground.

Ohio Court: Eminent Domain for Private Pipelines Unconstitutional

Private ethane pipeline to Canada is not a "public use" or "public necessity," as required by Ohio Constitution Ruling will protect property rights of Ohio farmers and other rural property owners Bowling Green, OH - An Ohio court ruled that private pipeline companies...

Pipeline impact

Taking of Ohioans’ Land for Private Pipeline Unconstitutional

15 families unite and move to dismiss corporation's case attempting to take their land through eminent domain. Columbus, OH - The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law moved to dismiss 16 separate eminent domain cases filed in Bowling Green, Ohio by Texas pipeline...

constitution

Ohio Cities’ Pre-Sale Home Inspections Unconstitutional

Legal Center moves to protect Ohioans' property rights from unlawful searches and fees statewide Columbus, OH - The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law moved in federal court to immediately enjoin Ohio cities, and the Cities of Bedford and Oakwood in particular, from...

donate_check

Top 10 Reasons to Donate to the 1851 Center . . . this Year!

This holiday season, as you're besieged by end of the year fundraising emails, don't overlook Ohio's only charity that consistently defends your constitutional rights and limits government. Here are a few reasons to make room in your budget to contribute to liberty in...

leaves

Ohioans Beware: State Issue 2

Proposed Constitutional Amendment would prohibit tax reform without stopping monopolies or marijuana legalization as promised Columbus, OH - The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law took action to clarify for Ohioans State Issue 2, which will appear on the November 3,...

Pipeline nix_

Ohio Cities May Not Immediately Seize Rural Township Properties

Eminent Domain Abuse Continues as Cities Attempt to Seize Land Beyond Their Borders, Overuse "Quick-Take" Columbus, OH - The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law has moved to counter the aggressive legal tactics taken by the City of Perrysburg, Ohio to immediately seize...

Amish

Update: Amish Daughter Healthy Despite Health Care “Experts”

I visited the home of Andy and Anna Hershberger to deliver the good news that the Medina County Probate Court had at long last formally terminated the guardianship it had created over their now 12-year-old daughter, Sarah. A government hospital, Akron Children's...

term limits

Proposed Amendment Will Strengthen Ohio’s Term Limits on Legislators

Columbus, OH -  The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law secured the approval necessary for a coalition of good government advocates to begin the circulation of a proposed constitutional amendment that would limit state legislators to no more than eight years in each...

coins

Ohio High Court Rebukes School District Tax Increase

Taxpayers cheated by Indian Hill School District's "Inside Millage Move", by raising taxes without public vote Cincinnati - Indian Hill School District's property tax increase without voter permission violated state law, according to unanimous ruling from the Supreme...

Red-light-camera

Legal Center to High Court: Traffic Cameras Unconstitutional in Ohio

Toledo's enforcement scheme for enforcing traffic camera infractions violates Ohio Constitution Columbus, OH - The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law  submitted to the Ohio Supreme Court its brief in Walker v. City of Toledo asserting that the City of Toledo's method...

teacher union words

Teachers Union Places 1851 on “Enemies” List

1851 Center responds to unearthed Ohio Education Association "Agenda." Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law issued the following response to news that Ohio's largest teachers union, the Ohio Education Association, has named it to its "enemies" list:...

chemotherapy

State’s Forced Chemotherapy on Amish Child Violates Parental Rights, Health Care Freedom Amendment

State sues to take Amish family’s daughter and force chemo on her after chemo nearly kills her and family chooses different treatment option

amishColumbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today began representation of Andy and Anna Hershberger, parents of Sarah Hershberger, a ten year old Amish girl upon whom the State of Ohio, through Akron Children’s Hospital, seeks to force an unnecessary and potentially-deadly form of chemotherapy.

ACA exchanges

Lawsuit: Ohio’s Attempted Medicaid Expansion Unlawful

Governor's end-run around the Ohio General Assembly violates the separation of powers, Controlling Board's vote impermissibly contradicts General Assembly intent Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law late yesterday moved in the Ohio Supreme Court, on...

PAC

U.S. Supreme Court Petitioned to Review Ohio PAC Laws

1851 Center asks United States Supreme Court to review Ohio Political Action Committee regulations on behalf of Geauga County blogger's First Amendment rights Columbus, OH - The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, in cooperation with the Washington D.C.-based Center...

jobs

High Court Will Determine Ohioans Right to Challenge JobsOhio

1851 Center argues that state taxpayers maintain standing to challenge the constitutionality of Corporate Welfare Columbus, OH - The Supreme Court of Ohio heard arguments on January 23 to determine the extent to which Ohioans may take legal action to force state...

utopia

Eminent Domain Abuse Continuing Along Ohio Pipeline Route

1851 Center stops abuse in Licking County, offers free assistance to property owners threatened with taking of property by private pipeline corporation Columbus, OH – The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today condemned a private pipeline corporation's continued...

Money Business success growing concept, Trees on pile of coins money and coins in jar over sun flare silhouette tone.

Charitable Donations

Our clients receive free legal representation thanks to the generosity of our donors. If you support our efforts to advance liberty and limit government, please consider making a tax-deductible donation to the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law. Use our Paypal...

first amendment

Legal Center to High Court: Ohio PAC Laws Violate First Amendment

1851 Center asks Ohio Supreme Court to review Ohio Political Action Committee regulations on behalf of Geauga County Blogger Columbus, OH - The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today applied to the Supreme Court of Ohio for jurisdiction over a case challenging the...

ACA word on tablet screen with medical equipment on background

1851 Center Applauds Kasich Agreement on Obamacare Exchange

Columbus, OH - The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law today registered its approval, on behalf of conservative and libertarian leaders throughout Ohio, of the Kasich Administration's agreement to refuse to implement a "state-run" Obamacare exchange. The...

Man-hiding

Ohio Candidates Can’t Hide Behind Anti-Tax-Pledge Statute

To hold their elected officials accountable, a conglomerate of conservative, libertarian, and tea-party groups representing Ohio taxpayers have recently devised two pledges for state legislative candidates. These pledges are directed toward educating Ohio voters as to...

big city tall building

Obamacare: The Way Forward in Ohio

Friends, You, like me, were no doubt inundated with punditry on the fallout of the Obamacare ruling last Thursday and Friday. We didn't follow suit. I did not found the 1851 Center to gab. We exist to advance liberty and limit government, whether we're taking the...

school

High Court Rebukes Attack on Cincinnati Charter Schools

CPS Deed Restrictions Against Charter and Private Schools Illegal, Cincinnati Charter Schools to Remain Open Columbus - Cincinnati Public Schools' (CPS) policy of prohibiting the sale of unused available public school buildings to charter schools and private schools...

New---Parental-Rights

Westerville Taxpayers Move to Repeal March Tax Increase

On May 7, 2012 taxpayers for Westerville Schools, with the representation of the 1851 Center,commenced circulation of an initiative petition to repeal the 6.71 mil tax increase narrowly approved in March after taxpayers defeated a similar measure at the November 2011...

medicaid

Center Participates in Civil Rights Forum

On April 4, 2012, The 1851 Center participated in an event conducted by The Ohio Advisory Committee to the United States Commission on Civil Rights. The forum was aimed at investigating barriers to economic development in the state of Ohio and was conducted at...

no smoking bar

1851 Center Efforts cited in Missouri News Horizon

On March 12, 2012, The Missouri News Horizon wrote about the economic damage caused by Kansas's ban on smoking in bars. The article details the hardships placed on small business owners and cites the efforts of the 1851 Center. Read the full article here.

ACA exchanges

Is an Obamacare Exchange Legal in Ohio?

  This 1851 Center analysis explains how the Ohio Health Care Freedom Amendment, Section 21 of Ohio's Bill of Rights, forbids Ohio officials from imposing Obamacare health care exchanges on Ohioans. The document also explores reasons that such exchanges are an...

ACA exchanges

Healthcare Freedom Amendment Discussion

Maurice Thompson discussed Issue 3 (The Ohio Healthcare Freedom Amendment) with Empower U, which is an initiative of several Tea Party groups, built to help educate people about limited government and fiscal responsibility.

taxburden

Center Provides A Guide to Reducing Your School District Tax Burden

Ohio school districts continue to surrender to political pressure at the collective bargaining table, failing to curtail school employees’ lucrative compensation packages. And while this undisciplined spending could manifest itself in the form of reasonable lay-offs...

teenage_worker_grocery_cashier

Workplace Freedom Amendment

Press conference for the unveiling of the Ohio Workplace Freedom Amendment, an effort to place a constitutional amendment before voters to make Ohio a Right to Work state.

citizens

Issue 2 Debate

Here, management-side labor attorney Gary Greenberg and union counsel Stephen Lazarus debate the legal impact of Senate Bill 5 at a forum hosted by the Columbus Chapter of the Federalist Society and the 1851 Center.

freedomwatch

Freedomwatch Appearance

Watch the latest video at video.foxnews.com Maurice Thompson and Judge Andrew Napolitano discuss how the government strays from the Constitution during a special taping of Fox News' Freedom Watch Live at OSU.

LA_SMOKING_BAN

OSU Federalist Society Address

Maurice Thompson addresses smoking bans, state constitutional law and private property rights during a presentation to the Ohio State University Moritz College of Law Federalist Society on January 13, 2011.

debate-adults

NPR Debate

1851 Center for Constitutional Law Executive Director Maurice Thompson debates liberal academics and activists on the significance of the nation’s guiding document on National Public Radio’s “To the Point” program. Thompson argues the Constitution is a binding contact...

Tea Party Tax Day

Ohio Tax Day

This is the Columbus Ohio Tax Day 2010 Tea Party.

Ohio AG flag

Ohio AG Certifies 1851’s Health Care Amendment Language

Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray certifies constitutional amendment language drafted by the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law on behalf of the Ohio Liberty Council as fair and truthful. The amendment seeks to block implementation of federal health care mandates.

Thompson Maurice

Maurice Thompson on ONN’s Capitol Square

1851 Center for Constitutional Law Executive Director Maurice Thompson discusses the Ohio Liberty Council's state constitutional amendment aimed at blocking implementation of the national health care reform law in Ohio. This is the first of two videos.

Ohio capitol square

Maurice Thompson on ONN’s Capitol Square

1851 Center for Constitutional Law Executive Director Maurice Thompson discusses the Ohio Liberty Council's state constitutional amendment aimed at blocking implementation of the national health care reform law in Ohio. This is the second of two videos.

maurice-thompson talking

Thompson Discussing Health Care Reform at a Tea Party Event

Chris Littleton, Ohio Liberty Council President, and Maurice Thompson, executive director of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, explain tea party groups' proposed constitutional amendment to stop mandated health care coverage from taking effect in Ohio. This is...

Tea Party Tax Day

Thompson Discussing Health Care Reform at a Tea Party Event

Chris Littleton, Ohio Liberty Council President, and Maurice Thompson, executive director of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, explain tea party groups' proposed constitutional amendment to stop mandated health care coverage from taking effect in Ohio. This is...

Maurice Thompson

Thompson Discussing Health Care Reform at a Tea Party Event

Chris Littleton, Ohio Liberty Council President, and Maurice Thompson, executive director of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, explain tea party groups' proposed constitutional amendment to stop mandated health care coverage from taking effect in Ohio. This is...

Ohio Tea Party event

Thompson Discussing Health Care Reform at a Tea Party Event

Chris Littleton, Ohio Liberty Council President, and Maurice Thompson, executive director of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, explain tea party groups' proposed constitutional amendment to stop mandated health care coverage from taking effect in Ohio. This is...

Tea-Party

Thompson Discussing Health Care Reform at a Tea Party Event

Chris Littleton, Ohio Liberty Council President, and Maurice Thompson, executive director of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, explain tea party groups' proposed constitutional amendment to stop mandated health care coverage from taking effect in Ohio. This is...

medicaid

Thompson Discussing Health Care Reform at a Tea Party Event

Chris Littleton, Ohio Liberty Council President, and Maurice Thompson, executive director of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, explain tea party groups' proposed constitutional amendment to stop mandated health care coverage from taking effect in Ohio. This is...

freedomwatch

Thompson During a Fox News Freedom Watch

Maurice Thompson and Judge Andrew Napolitano discuss how the government strays from the Constitution during a special taping of Fox News Freedom Watch live at OSU. This is the first of four videos.

flag preamble

Thompson During a Fox News Freedom Watch

Maurice Thompson and Judge Andrew Napolitano discuss how the government strays from the Constitution during a special taping of Fox News Freedom Watch live at OSU. This is the second of four videos.

constitution flag

Thompson During a Fox News Freedom Watch

Maurice Thompson and Judge Andrew Napolitano discuss how the government strays from the Constitution during a special taping of Fox News Freedom Watch live at OSU. This is the third of four videos.

Thompson Maurice

Thompson During a Fox News Freedom Watch

Maurice Thompson and Judge Andrew Napolitano discuss how the government strays from the Constitution during a special taping of Fox News Freedom Watch live at OSU. This is the fourth of four videos.

health-care-industry

How Ohio Can Fight National Health Care

In this video Maurice Thompson of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law explains why the proposed federal health care bills are problematic from a utilitarian, moral, and constitutional perspective. In part two Maurice will talk about how Ohio can fight the mandates....

reflex-test-on-knee

How Ohio Can Fight National Health Care

Maurice Thompson of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law explains how Ohio can fight unconstitutional health care mandates using the Ohio constitution. This is the second of two videos.

LA_SMOKING_BAN

Thompson Discusses the Smoking Ban

Maurice Thompson, legal counsel and director of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, discusses a Franklin County judge's decision in favor of the Columbus-area bar Zeno's, which had been cited with $30,000-plus in fines for breaking the statewide smoking ban. This...

smoking-ban

Thompson Discusses the Smoking Ban

Maurice Thompson, legal counsel and director of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, discusses a Franklin County judge's decision in favor of the Columbus-area bar Zeno's, which had been cited with $30,000-plus in fines for breaking the statewide smoking ban. This...

no-smoking

Thompson Discusses the Smoking Ban

Maurice Thompson, legal counsel and director of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, discusses a Franklin County judge's decision in favor of the Columbus-area bar Zeno's, which had been cited with $30,000-plus in fines for breaking the statewide smoking ban. This...

Do-Smoking-Bans

Thompson Discusses the Smoking Ban

Maurice Thompson, legal counsel and director of the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, discusses a Franklin County judge's decision in favor of the Columbus-area bar Zeno's, which had been cited with $30,000-plus in fines for breaking the statewide smoking ban. This...

Prescription drugs

Ohio Issue 2 Town Hall Forum

View the opening statement delivered by Maurice Thompson on October 19, 2009 during the Ohio Issue 2 town hall forum.

mannajpg

The Stowers Tell Their Story

Jacqueline and John Stowers talk about their lives before and after a police raid of their home in LaGrange, Ohio in an interview with Maurice Thompson.

republican-health-care

Ohio Voters Approve Health Care Freedom Amendment

On Nov. 8, 2011, Ohio voters voiced their strong opposition to overbearing and invasive health care mandates by passing the Ohio Health Care Freedom Amendment with 66% of the vote.  Drafted by the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, the amendment preserves the freedom...

health food store

Manna Storehouse appeals to the Ohio Supreme Court

On July 21, 2011, Manna Storehouse and the Stowers family, notoriously raided by a Health and Agriculture Department-led SWAT team for not maintaining a "retail food establishment" in operating their small, private-membership organic food cooperative in LaGrange,...

Corsi Ohio case_

Corsi v. Ohio Elections Commission

In an apparent retaliatory action against an outspoken critic, the Geauga County Board of Elections charged independent blogger Ed Corsi with violating campaign finance laws. The elections board forwarded a complaint to the Ohio Elections Commission (OEC), where Corsi...

Legal law concept image gavel

U.S. Supreme Court Strikes Down Arizona Public Financing of Elections

In Arizona Free Enterprise Club v. Bennett, the Supreme Court of the United States continued its strong record of supporting political speech against governmental interference. The Court held Arizona's system of using public funds to selectively fund campaigns...

Ohio state house

1851 Center Files Action to Expose Government Lobbying Records

Organizations Comprised of Local Governments Refuse to Disclose Lobbying Activity on Estate Tax and Government Spending Columbus--The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, on behalf of Relators Dayton Tea Party and Robert Scott, yesterday filed in the Ohio Supreme Court...

records

Dayton Tea Party v. Ohio Municipal League

Exposing Government Lobbying Records On June 2, 2011, The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, on behalf of Relators Dayton Tea Party and Robert Scott, filed a Public Records Complaint in the Ohio Supreme Court demanding Ohio Municipal League (OML) and Ohio Township...

ProbateTax1

Update: Estate Tax Repeal Signed into Law, Expires January 1, 2013

The legislature has passed a state budget that includes the repeal of Ohio's Estate Tax.  Special thanks to the team at http://www.endohioestatetax.com/ for their leadership in accomplishing a feat that no liberty group before them had accomplished:  the elimination...

no-smoking

High Court Reviewing Smoking Ban Constitutionality

On April 6, 2011, The Supreme Court of Ohio agreed to become the first state supreme court in the nation to determine whether a statewide smoking ban violates bar owners' property rights. The Court also agreed to review whether the Ohio Department of Health has...

Zenos

Jackson v. Bartec

This case is brought on behalf of Zeno’s Victorian Village, a family-owned Columbus tavern. The Center argues the smoking ban unconstitutionally deprives business owners of fundamental property rights. It also argues that the state health officials’ methods while...

jobs

Victory: “1851 Center Amendment” added to Senate Bill 5

Government employees would no longer have to "opt out" of making political contributions to unions, state government will no longer transfer political contributions to unions. The Ohio House of Representatives yesterday amended Senate Bill 5 to include the "1851...

theodore_roosevelt_school

Cincinnati Public Schools v. Conners

Cincinnati Public Schools has a policy of prohibiting the use of vacant public school buildings by charter schools and private schools. Historical Overview Theodore Roosevelt School, in Cincinnati, had purchased an unused school building located in the Fairmount...

corruption

Oleksa v. Murray

In October of 2010, Mansfield-area taxpayers filed an Ohio Corrupt Activities Act complaint against Gov. Ted Strickland, Ohio School Facilities Commission (OSFC) Executive Director Richard Murray, the Laborers’ International Union of North America (LIUNA) and others....

LA_SMOKING_BAN

Legal Center Asks High Court to Accept Smoking Ban Challenge

1851 Center Files Jurisdictional Motion with Ohio Supreme Court COLUMBUS - The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law, a public interest law firm, yesterday asked the Ohio Supreme Court to make a final determination on the legality of Ohio's state smoking ban, and its...

school money

AP: Suit against Ohio governor alleges favoritism

October 15, 2010 3:35 PM ET COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) - A libertarian legal center has sued Ohio Gov. Ted Strickland, key aides and a labor union alleging they engaged in a pattern of corrupt activity regarding school construction contracts. The 1851 Center for...

school money

Ohio RICO Complaint Filed to Stop School Construction Corruption

1851 Center Lawsuit alleges Strickland administration and OSFC placed union financial interests and remaining in office above fiscal responsibility in building schools. COLUMBUS – Tax dollars have been wasted and continue to be at risk due to an unlawfully cozy...

risk loan

Victory: Gahanna Backs Down on High-Risk Loan Fund

October 18, 2010 - Taxpayer Victory: Gahanna Indefinitely Postpones Ill-Advised $375K High-Risk Venture Capital Loan Fund Gahanna City Council indefinitely postponed a vote authorizing a city-backed $375,000 high-risk venture capital loan fund after the 1851 Center...

Erie shore ohio

Merrill v. State of Ohio Department of Natural Resources

September 14, 2011 - Ohio Supreme Court Protects Property Rights The court held that the State of Ohio extends to the natural shoreline, which is "the line at which the water usually stands when free from disturbing causes." The court reiterated its role as a...

Constitution-Day-2

Slingluff v. Andover Twp.

The First Amendment clearly protects the right to gather on the public square, speak out in support of limited constitutional government, and critique the current state of affairs. The government's action in this case, ironically, demonstrates the need for greater...

flag stethoscope

Is the Individual Mandate Unprecedented?

Back in March, Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray announced that Ohio would not be joining other state lawsuits against the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (the federal healthcare law) because the suits did not “have any legal merit whatsoever.” He based...

no-obamacare

Where is the State of Ohio in the Fight against Obamacare?

According to a March 2010 press release issued by Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray, our state will not be joining other state lawsuits against the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (the official name of the federal health care law) because the suits do...

traffic-camera

(WBNS 10TV) Watchdog: Red Light Camera Law ‘Fundamentally Flawed’

Tuesday, July 27, 2010 6:00 PM COLUMBUS, Ohio — Some critics on Tuesday said that the city's controversial red light camera program is fundamentally flawed and could be challenged in court. The city said that the red light camera program is about safety, but 10...

JudgeTexas

Judge sets charter school precedent

Public districts can no longer stop competitors from moving in to old buildings BY KIMBALL PERRY • Cincinnati Enquirer • June 1, 2010 CINCINNATI -- For the first time, a Hamilton County judge has allowed an exclusive exception to property deed restrictions that could...

sell school

Court: Cincinnati Public Schools Violated State Law

Judge Rules CPS Deed Restrictions Against Charter and Private Schools Illegal Columbus - Cincinnati Public Schools' (CPS) policy of prohibiting the sale of unused available public school buildings to charter schools and private schools violates state law, yesterday...

Gavel

Ohio Department of Commerce v. 770 West Broad AGA, LLC

770 West Broad AGA, a private contractor, entered into an agreement with the Ohio Department of Commerce to provide work space for the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Corrections. Under the lease terms, AGA made several improvements to the property at its own...

Do-Smoking-Bans

Maurice Thompson talks smoking bans on Detroit’s WJR-AM

With Michigan's recently enacted smoking ban about to go into effect, Frank Beckmann of WJR-AM Detroit spoke with 1851 Center Executive Director Maurice Thompson about his successful efforts challenging Ohio's smoking ban. Listen to the interview here: Interview Read...

ohio WestLibertyCouncil

Ohio Liberty Council v. Brunner

On March 22, 2010, the Ohio Liberty Council began the process of the placing a health care freedom constitutional amendment on the November 2010 ballot. The group filed petition summary language and nearly 3,000 signatures from registered voters in 48 counties with...

health care protest cartoon

Maurice Thompson w/ WTVN’s Bob Conners on health care admendment

1851 Center for Constitutional Law Executive Director Maurice Thompson and 610 WTVN's Bob Conners discuss the Ohio Liberty Council's effort to block new federal health care mandates through a constitutional amendment. The amendment language was drafted by the 1851...

first amendment

SpeechNow.org v. FEC

On September 1, 2009, the 1851 Center filed an amicus brief defending the First Amendment rights of SpeechNow.org in its legal battle with the Federal Elections Commission. The FEC viewed the non-profit much like a political action committee or PAC. The 1851 Center’s...

republican-health-care

Health Care Freedom Amendment

Ohio's Healthcare Freedom Amendment - Historical Overview      Twenty-six state legislatures have introduced bills to propose constitutional amendments to block the individual mandates contained in the new federal regulations, according to the National Conference of...

acorn

AP: ACORN gives up Ohio business license, won’t return

By JULIE CARR SMYTH (AP) Thursday, March 11, 2010 COLUMBUS, Ohio — The community organizing group ACORN has agreed to give up its Ohio business license and not return under another name, as it has in other states, under a settlement struck with a libertarian center...

acorn

Miller v. ACORN

In October 2008, the 1851 Center sued ACORN regarding its activities in Ohio. The action alleged ACORN engaged in a pattern of corrupt activity that amounted to organized crime due to its perpetual submission of fraudulent voter registrations in Ohio. The Center...

love donation

Drees Company v. Hamilton Township

Ohio Townships do not have the power to levy taxes.  That's why they call them "fees." This case argues that "fees" on new homeowners and developers are really taxes and are unconstitutional. Timeline February 14, 2011 - 1851 Center Files Amicus Brief at Ohio Supreme...

Protecting Health Freedom

Protecting Health Freedom

The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law drafted petition language aimed a fighting pending national health care regulations. Read the amendment news release and watch the news conference here. Download the petition here.  Visit the Ohio Liberty Council for more...

Moto Verde and the Village of Fairfax

Moto Verde and the Village of Fairfax

In July 2009, the 1851 Center advised the Village of Fairfax, an enclave in the city of Cincinnati, that it had violated the constitutional rights of Moto Verde. Moto Verde is a motor scooter shop, but the village had classified it as an automobile dealership, refused...

OH state house

A challenge to Ohio’s Mortgage Modification Bill

In March 2009, the 1851 Center submitted written and oral testimony to the Ohio General Assembly on House Bill 3, a bill that would allow Ohio’s trial judges to rewrite the terms of mortgage contracts.  The Center’s testimony made it clear that HB 3 was an...

smoking-ban

Pour House Inc., v. Ohio Department of Health

A victory came on October 19, 2009 for Ohio bars and restaurants facing fines for breaking the state smoking ban. Up to that point, enforcement methods essentially required small businesses to enforce the smoking ban for the government. The 1851 Center points out that...

mannajpg

Manna Storehouse v. Ohio Department of Agriculture

On the morning of December 1, 2008, law enforcement officers forcefully entered the Stowers' residence, without first announcing they were police or stating the purpose of the visit. With guns drawn, officers swiftly and immediately moved to the upstairs of the home,...

estate-tax-web

Victory: Ohio Estate Tax Repealed

The legislature has passed a state budget that includes the repeal of Ohio’s Estate Tax.  Special thanks to the team at http://www.endohioestatetax.com/ for their leadership in accomplishing a feat that no liberty group before them had accomplished:  the elimination...

Case Suggestions

Case Suggestions

If you have a case suggestion or if you believe your constitutional rights have been violated by the government please contact mthompson@buckeyeinstitute.org.

LetOhioVote.org v. Brunner

LetOhioVote.org v. Brunner

August 3, 2009: 1851 Center Files Amicus In Supreme Court Slots Case The 1851 Center for Constitutional Law filed an amicus brief in LetOhioVote.org v. Brunner with the Ohio Supreme Court. This filing supports a public vote on video slot machines at Ohio horse race...

COAST v. City of Cincinnati

COAST v. City of Cincinnati

In May 2009, the 1851 Center for Constitutional Law filed, in Federal Court, a motion to restrain the City of Cincinnati and its agents from harassing citizens who are demanding that the City put its $200 million trolley project to a vote. The Motion argues the City...

Ohio Grocer’s Association v. Wilkins

Ohio Grocer’s Association v. Wilkins

In May 2009, the 1851 Center filed an amicus brief in Ohio Grocers Association v. Wilkins. The brief argues that Ohio’s Commercial Activities Tax is an unconstitutional excise tax on food. It  is levied on Ohio grocers based on the amount of food they sell and grocers...

Toledo Planning Commission and Private Schools

Toledo Planning Commission and Private Schools

In December 2008, the 1851 Center issued a legal notice to the Toledo City Council and the Toledo Planning Commission advising that, if the City passed an ordinance applying “Minimum School Facilities Requirements” to private schools, the 1851 Center would pursue...